John Redwood's Diary
Incisive and topical campaigns and commentary on today's issues and tomorrow's problems. Promoted by John Redwood 152 Grosvenor Road SW1V 3JL

Anyone submitting a comment to this site is giving their permission for it to be published here along with the name and identifiers they have submitted.

The moderator reserves the sole right to decide whether to publish or not.

We fight too many wars

I backed a previous Labour government in keeping us out of the Viet Nam war.I could not see how that could have  a happy ending.

I failed to persuade the Conservative opposition to oppose UK involvement in the Iraq war. That too did not end well.

I have supported the last four Prime Ministers in their view that we should not go to war with Russia. This has meant not allowing any UK military personnel to help Ukraine in their country.

The UK did lose lives and commit plenty of money and equipment to the fight in Afghanistan, only to see the US pull  out without even consulting us. Defeat followed quickly, meaning all our sacrifices had been wasted.

Today the PM tells the world Ukraine must fight on to show Putin the use of force is not rewarded. How does that help when in more than 3 years of war Ukraine has not been able to evict Russian forces and he is not suggesting how this can change. Indeed, the UK cannot afford to offer more military  hardware and money and the US wants out from being the major donor.

 

I am pleased to read that the PM  now sees the UK and France cannot muster a sufficient force to guarantee any ceasefire or peace in Ukraine without US help. The UK is not currently equipped to fight and win a war with Russia without NATO and US leadership. The UK is not on a war footing and would need to turn massively to arms production and military recruitment to be so to assist Ukraine. If Europe cannot keep the US onside to help supply and support Ukraine it needs to avoid making promises it cannot keep, leaving Ukraine with insufficient support.

The run up to May 1

In the run up to the elections I am not posting messages that tell people to vote for any particular party, nor over the top and inaccurate attacks on parties.

The site encourages sensible discussion of government policy and options for the future to help inform the general public debate.

Beware the sell out

Various briefings hint at a big sell out to the EU in the forthcoming reset.

There is suggestion we will surrender most of our fish for  years ahead for no good reason.

There is a wish to bind us into more rules and regulations. This is said to be necessary to help trade in items like food. We already import far too much from the EU and all the time we were in the EU we faced a large trade deficit with the EU forcing out our farmers. Bad idea to volunteer for more of that. We lost a lot if market share with beef bans, too small a milk quota and grabts to grub up our orchards.

There is the idea of bringing back freedom of movement for younger people, calling it a Youth Mobility scheme. That would mean more large taxpayer bills to help these young people meet high housing and living costs.

We must try to stop this.

Smashing the gangs

So much for smashing the gangs. New records are being achieved this year for illegals coming across the Channel. The government that promised to close the migrant hotels is paying top prices to secure more of them. Meanwhile  they are trying to speed up giving many if the illegals the right to stay, acting as a further lure to many more to come.

We seem to get very little for all the money given to France to police this. Why don’t they puncture the boats before they can leave when they see the shire preparations to sail.? Why do they give  them free passage to mid point in the Channel, helping them we are told  with life belts and accompanying them  with a back up vessel? It would  be cheaper and safer to turn them back in the shallows by the shore.

When Border Force or a Lifeboat picks them up in mid Channel  to give them free and safer passage  to the UK who do they not arrange to arrest and question the boat organiser/ captain on arrival in England? Why are they not interrogated  to find out the rest of  the gang organising this dangerous business?

Why cant the UK authorities pose as mystery shoppers seeking seats on a small boat from France to help locate and arrest the organisers? We should expect more vigour and imagination in rounding up these boat exploiters. Catching them would be a good deterrent.

Hurrah for Shakespeare and St George

April 23 is an important date in any  Englishman’s diary. It marks both the birthday and the  date of death of our greatest dramatist and poet, William Shakespeare. It is the day we commemorate our country through our patron Saint, St George.

 

Shakespeare is one of those great achievers that made our history and contribution to mankind special. From Ebenezer’s Garden cities to Brunel in engineering, from Josiah Wedgwood’s  pioneering factory and ceramics  to Whittle and the jet, from Wren in architecture to Turner in painting England has offered much to the world.

Shakespeare’s genius was in capturing timeless human characteristics and emotions. Jealousy in Othello, violent ambition in Macbeth, the  inability to see and understand  in Lear’s  old age, the difficulty to avenge a crime in Hamlet ,the folly and fun of young love in Midsummer Night’s Dream are all spell binding accounts of modern feelings and events springing from their roots in Elizabethan and Jacobean England.

Shakespeare turned the Globe stage into many exotic scenes, from Venice to Denmark, from  a French to an English battlefield, from court to country, from palace to a hovel. Most of the transitions were conjured in audience imagination by the power of words. Bon mots, jests, epigrams, perfect soundbites poured from his quill and enrich our modern language.

What fools these mortals be said Puck. To be or not to be agonised Hamlet. The Fool said to Lear  you should not have been old til though hadst been wise. John of Gaunt spoke for England ,  in words we should all remember. Our land is indeed a sceptred isle, a blessed plot, this earth, this realm, this england.

 

Let’s draw up a list of all the businesses the government is undermining

Any new oil and gas investment is banned. The aim is to close down our industry quickly.

Any factory making petrol and diesel cars needs to be closed by 2030.

No new coal mines allowed. Industry largely dead.

Virgin steel manufacture. Only 2 blast furnaces left. How long will the government pay to keep those going. Industry undermined by high energy prices  and taxes.

Aluminium  All but one  smelter closed by high energy costs

Coal fired power stations. All closed, many blown up to prevent future use

Oil refining being wound down. Grangemouth now shut.

Petro chemicals and chemicals being wound down

Most ceramics production sent abroad

Self employment reduced by hostile tax regime

Fishing industry decimated by Common Fishing Policy and so called Transition

Dairy  farming was limited  by EU shortage of milk quotas for UK

UK orchards were grubbed up with EU grants

Current farming policy gives grants to stop food growing

 

 

 

 

 

We cannot be best friends of the EU, China and US at the same time

UK foreign policy is based on two false assumptions. We can have best friend relationships with the EU , China and the US at the same time. Giving in to the demands of foreign governments buys us friends. These policies instead  makes us weak , subject to more  unacceptable demands.

Recognising public anger  about this the government doubles up on this stupidity  whilst  changing the words to say this is representing the national interest.

How is it in the national interest to give the Chagos  away along with billions? Whose support and favour will that buy?

How is it good to give in to the EU over  fish, free movement of young people and accepting their laws? They  will just ask for more.What do we get back?

How is it sensible to import  more and more energy and food from the EU when we could produce our own?

How is it wise to depend on China for steel, for solar panels, for wind turbines and electric cars?

Why do we say we need to do more damage to our industry to pursue net zero to lead the world when the world does not follow?

 

Why does the government give so much money away to foreign governments?

As the government mugs pensioners and sets out to take money away from the disabled, it finds plenty of foreign governments to give it to.

There is the large sum for Mauritius to go alongside the shameful  gifting of the Chagos islands.

There is the promise of an expensive intervention in Ukraine and new money and weapons for them

There are the large sums paid to France to stop the gangs, only to see the French escort more across the Channel

There are the huge sums on hotels for illegals after promises to close down all those  contracts.

There is money for Sudan.

Many voters have had enough of foreign governments first.

 

Get our tariffs down, PM

As soon as President Trump proposes and imposes some reciprocal  tariffs the UK and EU establishment explodes with rage. They are right that tariffs are taxes on consumers in the country that imposes the tax, with some  of the burden shifted to the exporters  where consumers cut back or succeed in getting some producer offset to the price hike. So knowing this why do they impose some high tariffs themselves?

They have also failed to confess that they impose plenty of non tariff barriers on trade making imports too dear or banning some of them altogether. The single  market is  a Customs Union, not a free trade area. It aims to stop foreign competitors by rules and tariffs.

Take beef. The UK still imposes a 12% tariff and £1.47 per kg on beef from outside Europe, but  we allow free access for Irish beef. No wonder they clean up on imports, avoiding US competition thanks to tariffs and EU/UK bans on some US production. In many cases our tariffs and regulations are a bigger barrier to imports than US restrictions on our exports to them.

Hitching ourselves to the EU more will be back to our EU experience. It meant dearer food and more imports from the EU. They took most of our fish, banned our beef for a long tine, kept us short of milk quota  and gave grants to rip out our orchards.