The government behaves as if UK taxes and public spending are too low. It complains about past government austerity. It sets bizarre fiscal rules based around OBR forecasts of five years hence that are bound to be wrong. It puts up taxes on jobs and assets that were bound to destroy growth and lead to an exodus of wealth and talent. The media helps them frame a debate about this illusory world of past austerity and present false choices.

The truth is the last six years have seen an explosion of public spending, up 55% in cash terms and up strongly in real terms. Inflation was around 25% so the real increase was around 30%.  There has been a major expansion of the civil service, of NHS staff and of employees in the wide public sector. There has been no shortage of cash or  people. There has been a collapse in productivity.

At the same time there has been a large increase in low income and no income legal migrants, and in illegal migrants who get to stay. This has driven up demand for subsidised housing, utilities and a wide range of public services.

The way to control public spending is to put an end to mass migration , and to engage urgently and purposefully with the need to  get productivity above 2019 levels again. The  state should not be spending more but spending better, It should not be inviting in hundreds of thousands to add to housing and NHS waiting lists.

The Labour government of Harold Wilson sent  every voter a pamphlet advising us to vote to stay in the EEC. A crucial promise was made

”There was a threat  to employment in Britain from the movement in the Common Market towards an Economic and Monetary Union. This could have forced us to accept fixed exchange rates for the pound, restricting industrial growth and so putting jobs at risk . This threat has been removed”

Well it was not. As they rightly forecast EMU would  destroy jobs which is what happened when the UK was pushed into it by all 3 main parties.

The tract also assured us we would not lose our Parliamentary sovereignty. It said

”It is the Council of Ministers who take the important decisions…The Minister representing Britain can veto any new law or tax if he considers it to be against British interests”

Instead the EEC/EU went over to qualified majority votes where we could be ignored or overridden.

I find it odd that hardened Remain supporters claim moral and intellectual superiority whilst reading and understanding little of the EU or our relationship with it.

They think the Uk can only grow if we sell more goods to the EU. At the same time their net zero policies ban the oil, gas, oil products, petrol and diesel cars that made up the leading items we exported. I set out yesterday for them the big surge in service exports to non EU and how our trade is now dominated  by services and non EU markets, but they will ignore that.

Now they want the Uk to be able to get some money and orders  out of a borrowed fund of 150 bn the EU plans for weapons they are  buying.Why? We have our own money to buy weapons. We need to use that to expand  our own weapons industry.  If we joined in their fund we would need to take joint responsibility for all the extra debt. They will need to buy from UK companies if they want certain products anytime soon. If they refuse it will be their loss.

The PM has shown how divided over  Ukraine the EU is. He has demonstrated that NATO remains our best way of encouraging defence collaboration. He has also proved that as in 1940 the UK has to arm to be able to defend our islands without European help.

France wants to grab more of our fish, and prevent us rebuilding our once self sufficiency with our own trawlers. We need to take back control as transition in fish ends. They have plundered our seas and taken most of our fish for far too long.

They want to put us back under their  laws , pretending that would be good for trade. UK companies need to be free to design and make things for global markets, not impeded by the EU single recipe.

• The bulk of our economic activity is home output for UK people. More than half our overseas trade is with non EU countries and over half our trade is in services, not goods. Yet  many in government go on and on about how to get growth we need to boost exports of goods to Europe. Remain supporters cling to the long disproven idea that our goods trade with the EU would fall with Brexit and lead to lower GDP.

The main reason the UK is not growing today is the anti business budget last year which stopped a good growth in the first half of the year and threatens more damage to UK business when the jobs tax kicks in in April.indeed, growth in just the first quarter of 2024 was more than the Bank of England forecast for the whole of 2925 after the disaster  budget.

Since 2016 when we decided  to leave the EU exports are up from £575 bn to £837 bn or 45%. Since we left in 2020 they are up from £624 bn or a third. They are up by more with the rest of the world than the EU and services are up by more than goods,  but that was also the trend in our later tears in the EU. The EU has been growing too slowly. The rest of the world has been growing faster and is keener on our exports.

Trump tariffs have not yet had any effect on the  numbers. Their inflationary effects will be the US, not on us.  The UK did scrap all EU tariffs on intermediates when we left the EU and all tariffs on goods we do not make, to stop taxing ourselves. The UK should drop the damaging carbon border tax or tariff which the EU proposed and which we have still not dropped. It will put up our inflation and anger the US, inviting retaliation.

Current Uk industrial and energy policies are designed to drive down our goods and oil exports by banning oil,gas, petrol  and diesel cars and by giving us such dear energy our high energy using  industries cannot compete. It is the net zero policy, not Brexit that will lose us national output and exports.

The coalition of the willing is not needed. If there is no peace to police there is no need. If there is an eventual ceasefire Putin will not accept UK troops in Ukraine.

Instead there is a bigger moral and political choice to be made. Ukraine wants many more weapons and ammunition. The US is wanting to supply less. Should European countries greatly increase their support for Ukraine and for a longer war? Should the UK do more?

Measured as a percentage of GDP the US and UK have led with gifts of military equipment. Germany has been the best of the major EU countries. France and Italy have been the laggards offering under a third  of the US/UK levels.

Getting Ukraine to fight  on alone means more deaths and destruction but could it bring victory? There is rightly no US/ UK wish to go to war with Russia.

There is a case to say as the EU has strong views on the Russian invasion and has land frontiers with Russia and Ukraine we should expect all these  EU countries who have so far contributed little to pick up the  challenge. France could lead  it as her President makes plenty of warlike speeches.

The struggle is after all between Russia seeking to govern Ukraine after seizing it by violent invasion, and the EU governing Ukraine after helping   a Ukraine government that supports EU membership  .

The UK should step up defence spend but on home defence.Our needs are better defences against missile and drone attack, and  an enhanced navy and airforce to protect our islands and trade routes.

Labour and Conservative agree the welfare bill is too high and growing too fast. They both agree it needs to be brought down by helping hundreds of thousands of people of working age into jobs. They are both particularly worried about 1 million young people not in education, employment or training.

Labour flirted with the idea of cutting the real value of Personal Independence payments.That was a bad idea. People need to be assessed and then paid extra  money to get the support they need to assist in managing their disability.

Second thoughts led them to decide to make it more difficult to qualify for the payment.

Labour also think they need to tighten criteria for other benefits, and remove entitlements for under 22 s. Presumably they will look into the surge in mental health cases. Some argue that whilst people with recognised medical conditions that need medication or other treatment of course need benefits, too many are unhappy or out of sorts but are not mentally ill. Getting a job and entering into the activity and social contact that work brings could be helpful to the person. There remains the issue of conditionality. How many job offers can someone turn down whilst still keeping full benefits?

It is difficult to achieve the change of behaviours government wants in such a large and expensive system. They are talking about a possible saving if £5 bn in five years time. They have promised an extra £1 bn spend on helping people into work. This needs legislation. Difficult see any savings this year or next.

They should cut back severely on work visas and legal migration and reverse the anti business budget if they really want to get many more off benefits and into jobs.

The attack on Shakespeare by a Trust set up to commemorate a great writer is yet another unwelcome essay in loathing our history, culture and traditions.

Many of us wish to be proud of our country, to remember its best days, its finest hours, its greatest people and its best achievements.

William Shakespeare is admired, read and enacted all round the  world. He is generally acclaimed as a great writer, able to capture eternal truths about human nature and the human condition. His words, characters and plots cross the centuries and national boundaries all round the world.

I will write occasional pieces about our history and the great causes and achievements our country has recorded. Today I begin with a brief comment on the great figures I particularly revere.

I rate Elizabeth I as a great politician who survived threats to her life whilst  her Catholic sister was Queen to emerge as England’s greatest monarch.

I regard William Shakespeare as the world’s greatest dramatist.

J Turner was a great artist. His Fighting Temeraire captures the passing of the age of sail to steam, as Rain, Steam and Speed  records the arrival of the railway.

Josiah Wedgwood was a great entrepreneur who changed the face of ceramics, developed marketing,  built  an advanced  factory and pioneered better treatment of employees.

Nelson was the greatest military captain, containing and defeating the imperial forces of Napoleon.

I am pleased to see my long standing interest in the collapsing productivity of the UK public sector has now  become a central government preoccupation . They are right that the public accounts have been driven out of balance by a £40 bn loss of productivity since 2019. There are things they can do to wrestle it back.

They should start with a freeze on all external recruitment of people other than medics, teachers and uniformed personnel,This would slim staff numbers by around 7% a year, or 140,000 posts. Ministers should have the  power to approve outside appointees where there is a bad skills shortage in the public sector.

Abolishing NHS England can help if good decisions are made about how much is still run from the centre  and by whom in the Health Department. Saving 9000 posts if they do achieve that is small in a service employing more than 1.5 million full time equivalents. If they are getting rid of senior managers redundancies can be costly and are upsetting to some  who stay as well as to those who are fired.

Sir Kier talks about deregulating and   stripping out unwanted independent bodies. The Lord Chancellor had the perfect chance this week to get rid of the Sentencing Council when she said she disagreed with its most recent report and decisions. Her failure to back a Conservative amendment to the law to sort this out shows this policy has yet to embed in government actions.

It is difficult to assemble a coalition of the willing to keep or enforce a peace which has not yet been negotiated. So far 25 countries including some outside Europe have been willing to talk, but there has been less clarity about how much money and or how many troops they would each contribute to peace keeping.

Meanwhile the possibility of  peace rests on the talks between the US and Russia and the US and Ukraine. Russia has made additional demands to the outline agreement the US has persuaded Ukraine to accept in principle. One of those is no troops from NATO countries to be in any peace keeping force in Ukraine. It has already been accepted that Ukraine will not join NATO.

It is possible Russia could give up this demand but unlikely. It makes NATO countries planning a peacekeeping force premature. It is a very long potential border between Ukraine and Russia, so it would need  a large force if the idea is soldiers patrolling a neutral area along the border.

Little is clear about this proposal, save the important point that the European countries of NATO have no power to commit NATO and have no intention of sending any personnel in to help fight the current war. The EU is struggling to increase armament supply to Ukraine to replace the US resources.

Yesterday’s figures showed another small fall in GDP in January and very little growth over 3 months. No surprises.

The industrial decline I and others have been predicting proceeds apace. Industry and oil and gas fell again. There are the high taxes on car sales with the attack on popular cars throttling the vehicle industry.There is the ban on new oil and gas exploration and development speeding the energy decline. There is the upcoming closure of our last blast furnaces hitting steel . There is the closure of Grangemouth and the persistent damage being done to high energy using industries by our high energy prices.

If the government wants growth and wants more to happen outside London and the south east it needs to reverse these  de industrialisation policies. The PM needs to reshuffle Miliband out of the Energy and Net Zero department and put in someone who does see the folly of switching to imports.

Meanwhile the Chancellor’s high tax policy is hitting small businesses, services and confidence. Still to come is the full imoact of the NI increase this April which will hit employment and lead to more closures of shops, pubs and restaurants.