Mansion House – more spin or confession time?

At the Mansion House tonight the government will doubtless tell us the economic problems of Britain come from a global crisis – they are more the result of sub prime USA, not a sub Prime Minister. Our attention will be turned by attentive spin doctors and gullible media to wicked oil producers overcharging for petrol and diesel, and to greedy speculators chasing up the price of food and other commodities. We will doubtless be given huge reassurances that the UK is being managed well in the circumstances, that the UK economy will keep on growing despite it all, and the inflation will be temporary.

If that is the message, it won’t wash. It will reinforce most people’s impressions that the government either does not know what is going on, or is so steeped in the business of disinformation that they cannot help themselves. It is probably a combination of the two. They have spun their line so many times, many of them now do probably believe it. They may once have understood the need for Prudence, for proper management of the public sector, for avoiding nationalisation and going with the grain of markets, but they have forgotten much of that in their crude political rush to spend money wherever they wrongly think it might buy them votes.

What the government should say tonight if it wished to re-establish some economic authority would be very different. They could of course point out that the Credit Crunch is an international phenomenon, but they should tell people part of it is made in Britain. They should admit that the handling of Northern Rock was unique British bungling, and set about repairing the Bank of England before the crisis gets much older. They need to restart the sale process for Northern Rock and get it back into the private sector as quickly as possible, to limit the amount of damage they have to do to the business by running it down, exacerbating the shortage of housing finance.

They should accept that past errors of monetary control have helped fire the inflation we are now experiencing. They should say that now there is a cruel dilemma – should they mainly fight inflation with high interest rates, or fight slowdown and possible recession with lower rates? If they would take some of the pressure off the economy by moving to reduce wasteful public spending and lower the government’s borrowing requirement, they could then risk lower interest rates, and start to give a little hope to the collapsing housing market.

Proposing some self discipline on public spending, instead of the sorry rake’s progress which passes for a public spending policy, could make a lot of difference. The large transport schemes they favour should be privately financed. Regional government, ID cards, central computerisation schemes, extra civil servants, more laws and regulations – these are all luxuries we cannot afford and many of us think we do not need. Let’s have a few billion off public spending by axing these and similar costs. Let’s have a staff freeze on the public sector, exempting teachers, medical staff, police, armed services personnel and other key front line professionals.

That would send a message to markets that the government would take some of the pain of adjustment, as excess demand is removed and borrowing reduced. At the moment an honest Chancellor would have to say that all the adjustment is planned for individuals and families, which means a year or more of greatly reduced mortgage finance, of rising prices going up faster than wages, falling house prices and a cut in real incomes. This will be especially savage on the lower paid.

This entry was posted in Blog. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

3 Comments

  1. tim holden
    Posted June 18, 2008 at 9:08 am | Permalink

    Buying votes is an expensive exercise, and a government dependent on such a process has had to pay in advance. It would seem that the taxpayer can no longer afford to participate in the arrangement, as was always inevitable. The massive retrospective costs of termination pay and pensions are the issue that the next government needs to address.

  2. mikestallard
    Posted June 18, 2008 at 9:28 pm | Permalink

    When I was very poor myself, I cut back on food, heat, light and transport. It worked (just) and we got through the 1970s as a family.
    Economics is, as you suggest, that simple. The government needs to do what I did – urgently.
    So it must be very frustrating for people like you, John, who can clearly see what needs to be urgently done, to sit on the sidelines watching the economy degenerate into chaos.
    I think you are in for a big disappointment this evening therefore. Yvette Cooper being lambasted on Newsnight yesterday points this up.

  3. Steve
    Posted June 19, 2008 at 10:22 am | Permalink

    I find myself having to pinch myself when I see Yvette Cooper on the television. She is introduced as the Chief Secretary to the Treasury. Can this be true? No matter how hard I pinch I don't wake up.

    Her previous experience as housing minister – presiding over the biggest credit boom in history – can surely not fit her for a role in the Treasury.

    Home Information Packs eh? Has any buyer ever asked to see one? Has any buyer's solicitor ever failed to commission their own searches – rather than relying on the ones paid for by the vendor and, by definition, more or less out of date.

  • About John Redwood


    John Redwood won a free place at Kent College, Canterbury, He graduated from Magdalen College Oxford, has a DPhil and is a fellow of All Souls College. A businessman by background, he has been a director of NM Rothschild merchant bank and chairman of a quoted industrial PLC.

  • John’s Books

  • Email Alerts

    You can sign up to receive John's blog posts by e-mail by entering your e-mail address in the box below.

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    The e-mail service is powered by Google's FeedBurner service. Your information is not shared.

  • Map of Visitors

    Locations of visitors to this page