The Chancellor finds his flexible friend to spend and borrow more

The budget will be full of extra borrowing as the government tries to find ways to boost GDP through bigger spending programmes and additional public sector investment. John Healey  inherited plans from Rachel Reeves to spend £145 bn more and borrow £97 bn more in 2027-8 than the outgoing Conservative plans for that year set out in the 2024 forecast. This big increase was only possible thanks to Reeves relaxing the fiscal rules and saying there would be better control on spending in the final fifth year of the forecast. She made the Fiscal rules  her flexible friend, to help disguise her spending binge.
Mr Burnham  does not think that enough. There is the unfunded increase in defence they are pledged to deliver. There are the growing claims of the nationalised industries, the soaring benefits bill and the surge in public sector wages. As tax has already been pushed up by £66 bn from the Reeves tax raids, and as some taxes now yield less as the rates go up, this government will likely go in for concealed extra borrowing. There might be a  tax raid on the banks as well, just when they need them to lend more to power growth.
The government is likely to rummage  through the worst of the Gordon Brown funny money playbook  of Private/public financings. Take   Sizewell, a new nuclear project. The government owns 44% of it so it says it does not have to put it on its balance sheet as it is just below 50%. However the Treasury will borrow over £36 bn to build it. It will pass that money to the National Wealth Fund who will lend it for interest to Sizewell, secured against putting an extra charge into everyone’s electricity bill.
Under the Reeves relaxation if the government borrows to spend on a new asset it can net the value of the asset off the borrowing when calculating state debt for the fiscal rules. So if you take out a mortgage you could say I do not have any debt because the house is worth more than the borrowings. Yet you do have a real debt and need to pay the interest on it. You could pay off the debt by selling the house but then you would be homeless, facing big rent bills.
The government’s biggest investment spend is on HS2, now likely to cost around £100 bn. As this government has pledged a nationalised railway it should not deduct a value of the track from the borrowings. Were government policy to change and sale became a possible option, what value would you put on it? It is likely to be a heavily  loss making line after allowing for the interest charges on the debt. A new owner would probably want the debt written off, so its value would be small at best and negative if the buyer had to take debt.
The government thinks the state financing bodies, National Wealth Fund, British Business Bank and Great British Energy are ways of increasing spend from more borrowing without counting as state debt. This will need careful analysis as the likelihood  is the risk remains with the state so the  extra  debt should  count as a state liability.
  They are also looking at a way of getting borrowing into defence to up defence spend without it counting as state debt. If it is expansion of private sector defence contractors with proper risk transfer to them then that could work, but not if the risk and effective  debt obligation remains with the taxpayer.
Next year Sizewell will probably need over £6 bn and HS 2 £3 bn, around £10 bn for the pair. British Steel will need £500m for losses without any money for the replacement electric arc furnace they are discussing. Council houses are a lot dearer in public spending terms than Housing Association, where the private money is not regarded as state debt.
The budget will be a wonder of creative accounting, delayed decisions and unfunded liabilities.

36 Comments

  1. Peter
    October 26, 2026

    ‘ The budget will be a wonder of creative accounting, delayed decisions and unfunded liabilities.“

    The reaction to this will be interesting. Denis Healey gave us the IMF crisis in 1976. In those days we still used to manufacture a lot. Nowadays we rely on the service industry.

    1. Ian Wragg
      October 26, 2026

      I bet the Bond vigilantes are circling. They will not be fooled by cloak and dagger shenanigans by Healey. Like his namesake he’s heading for the rocks.
      The amount needed to pay the interest on government borrowing is an embarrassment and totally unsustainable.
      Our Wes let the cat out of the bag when he said we have 1000 days to prepare for war. That takes us to July 2029 just before an election is due and a state of emergency is declared. So no General Election.
      Shysters the lot of them

    2. Peter
      October 26, 2026

      On the other hand, ‘Conservatives Home’ predicts a low key budget. They say this will buy time for a low key election early next year, before it all gets so bad that the whole electorate notice and before the opposition have time to mount a really strong challenge.

  2. Mark B
    October 26, 2026

    Good morning.

    The snake continues to eat its own tail.

    I expect more taxes and more regulation leading to more indirect taxation and eventual fines (another tax) for non-compliance. I expect those who create wealth to be expected, nay made, to give to those who do not create any. I expect more waste in government contracts, overspend and delays.

    The hole is getting deeper and deeper, and still they keep digging.

    1. Lynn Atkinson
      October 26, 2026

      They will not believe that the Government, on borrowed money, can’t spend its way to growth, until they are bankrupted.

    2. Lifelogic
      October 26, 2026

      “Made to pay tax surely” not BURNHAM promised they would only be “asked to pay a little more”. Was he lying? Surely not!

      It seems to me Labour are trying to keep election options open by doing nothing to address the economy properly. JUST DEALING WITH TRIVIA like pork scratchings, parking fines , bus fares… They will not have an early election as they cannot not win one – in my view.

    3. Lifelogic
      October 26, 2026

      “The Chancellor finds his flexible friend to spend and borrow more” well to borrow more to pay the interest on the £Trillions of debt they already have the remaining 10% to be spend on augmenting the fit but feckless and non working benefit claiments, accomodating illegal immigrants and providing dentistry, legal aid and NHS services and dealing the all the extra crimes created by releasing dangerous criminals from jails and importing criminals too.

      Should go well – but then the interest rates will rise further so that 10% may disapear and the tax take will fall further as people leave or change behaviour and confidence falls further. A brilliant Burnham, Reeves and Healey. Then they want to further damage the economy by rejoining the anti-democratic EU! What will the fee for that be and the vast further damage done by it.

  3. Wonderer
    October 26, 2026

    This points to more printing, more currency debasement, more inflation.
    Bond yields on a helter skelter.
    A kind of Covid 2.0 with a different scare factor involved.
    Things could easily get out of hand

  4. Berkshire Alan
    October 26, 2026

    Your last line says it all John, “creative accounting” only ever used if you want to hide the truth !

    HS2 will end up costing £1 Billion a mile, the most expensive railway in the World, and for what gain ?

    Yet more taxes, more complicated rules & regulation, all means less incentive for the working population !
    So why bother.?

    The Government preaches growth, but growth in what, DEBT and TAXATION !

  5. Lynn Atkinson
    October 26, 2026

    ‘Creative accounting’ in the private sector is known as ‘fraud’.

  6. John Westlake
    October 26, 2026

    Your analysis and revelations of Treasury so-called funny money accounting practices is quite a revelation, if not totally surprising, However, there is nothing funny about it even if Treasury accountants and the government may find it all terribly clever. Above and beyond all the policy arguments from political parties as to what policies our country should follow, one senses in everyday contacts amongst ordinary decent people that there is an increasingly widespread total loss of trust in politicians in general. This should be regarded as a lightning bolt to all political parties but I don’t feel they see it that way. Instead they will continue to pretend to the public, to mislead, to not quite lie, to prevaricate and make things worse.

  7. Narrow Shoulders
    October 26, 2026

    The Kwarteng budget was received well in the house, it was only analysis in the next few days combined with the Bank of England’s actions that sunk it.

    John Healy is not out of the woods until Saturday.

    Politicians of all colours reach for the borrowing stick too often and too easily. And the bond markets, making interest and yields off made up money continue to facilitate it.

  8. Lifelogic
    October 26, 2026

    Steve Baker: an ex RAF as an engineer just now said that had the Tories not solved Covid quickly (with their Covid vaccines, lockdowns, Midazolam used to kill I assume he means) the economy would not have recovered so quickly. This is clearly drivel as he must surely know he is not that stupid. They spent over £600bn but as we know the Covid “vaccines” and Covid Lockdowns did net harms. The vast majority needed no vaccines even had the vaccines been safe and effective (and they were not) the lockdowns just delayed natural vaccinations.

  9. mickey taking
    October 26, 2026

    I think the leaves have fallen off the money tree. Healey will announce an attempt to polish the bare branches, but the fact remains of evidence that the tree is going into more advanced death. Investment in treating the roots is an unlikely step, but we wait to applaud?

  10. Stred
    October 26, 2026

    The excellent engineers of South Korea manage to build nuclear power stations for around on sixth of the cost of the European Pressurised to be built at Hinkley and Sizewell. The French built high speed railways at a fraction of the cost of HS2.
    But the British civil service are masters of fiddling the books. Burnham and Healey are the Arthur Daley and minder of politics.

  11. Lifelogic
    October 26, 2026

    See the excellent and delightful Dr Claire Craig on the John Campbell video “Expired, unnecessary deaths” and her excellent book. It seems the government are not only absurdly hiding & refusing to release health data broken down by vaccines status – but have now also now stopped collecting it. Far too damning must be the reason. But surely not doing so is criminal?

  12. Bryan Harris
    October 26, 2026

    The budget will be a wonder of creative accounting, delayed decisions and unfunded liabilities

    We expect nothing less of the labour party – the party of pointless taxation!

    Meanwhile we should also concern ourselves with what is happening at the UN:
    The UN agenda is responsible for all of the ideology we have come to hate –

    Abortion, dressed up as “healthcare” for women and girls.
    Sex education designed so that your child or grandchild learns about sex before learning to pray, and learns about it from a stranger, not from you.
    Teaching children as young as seven to question whether they are boys or girls, and calling that doubt a human right.
    Abortion slipped into a document about pandemics.

    The UN’s agencies pass it on to your country’s ministries. Those ministries write it into teacher training. And by the time it reaches your child’s or grandchild’s desk, nobody can say who made the decision. And nobody asked you.

  13. Ian B
    October 26, 2026

    All that doom & gloom – that is real. Yet the latest opinion polls show Burnham’s New Labour storming ahead in the opinion polls – as much as 50%! ahead of all their rivals.

    I find it hard to believe these polls the seem contrived at times. Also among the people I know I cant find anyone that sees this UK Parliament is doing ‘a job’, let alone a good job. Obviously the circle I am in.

    The general appearance given off by this UK Parliament that none of them are worth the trouble to vote for, as none of them appear to be on the same wave length of those they pretend to represent. So it looks like more disenfranchising of the UK’s mainstream only the only vote being garnered by the idealogical terrorist that are ruled by hypocrisy

  14. miami.mode
    October 26, 2026

    The economy since 1992 can resemble a very slow motion version of a motorcycle racer’s highside crash.

    At the ERM the the bike snakes wildly off the line until Ken Clarke assisted by Robin Leigh-Pemberton and Steady Eddie George gets it upright and accelerating (why Ken Clarke was a Europhile after witnessing the ERM debacle is a mystery).

    Gordon Brown takes over and it enters the first corner. The rear wheel starts to slide out, panic overtakes the rider and the throttle is rolled off far too much in the ensuing years. The rear wheel loses rotation, the tyre then grips the tarmac and the bike violently snaps into an upright position when the current lot take over and the rider is thrown high into the air and the bike crashes.

  15. Ian B
    October 26, 2026

    Lord Redwood, you have it all wrong. Look at what Brown gave us. A taxpayer debt of £168 Billion in bailouts, nationalsiation, and ‘his’ up and coming ‘cool cat’ wiz kid finacial advisors in Burnham and Milliband that navigated his finacial crisis for him

    History? pah phooey nothing is learnt from History, that place is for the out of touch loonies (sarc)

  16. Peter Lloyd
    October 26, 2026

    If private sector companies did this then the Financial Regulators and Government would be all over them. It would be called scandalous, possibly illegal, immoral and immediate efforts made to stop it via the regulators and, if necessary, legislation which would be supported by justifiably angry Labour backbenchers and probably many other MPS.

  17. Bryan Harris
    October 26, 2026

    A day barely passes without more scare stories of AI being aired – Yes, we must be careful with this new tool, for it has promised to escape and do harm if we are not careful.

    We should follow the example of Asimov who compiled the the 3 laws of robotics, many years ago now, but they do give an example of how we can prevent AI from running wild:

    A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
    A robot must obey orders given by human beings, except when those orders conflict with the First Law.
    A robot must protect its own existence, as long as that doesn’t conflict with the First or Second Law.


    Properly thought out rules like the above hard wired into all AI systems should resolve any issues before they start:

    AI system may not cause or allow any injury to a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
    AI must obey orders given by human beings, except when those orders conflict with the First Law.
    AI robot must protect its own existence, as long as that doesn’t conflict with the First or Second Law,.
    AI must never assume it can act in a destructive manner against mankind, no matter the justification.

  18. Johan Knies
    October 26, 2026

    And in the same time paying twice for the debt. The bonds markets are having a bonanza.

  19. Bloke
    October 26, 2026

    My estimation is that Healey with borrow MUCH more, on the basis that paying for defence is most important. He may even surprise many by exceeding the NATO target just to make a point.

    He may try to justify it by claiming that it is the best way forward in present circumstances.
    That being so, what’s the guessing that even with the increased borrowing, he attempts to soften the shock by comparing our then-higher gdp to debt ratio as still being below those of: France, Italy, Greece, US, Singapore, and half that of Japan?

  20. Keith from Leeds
    October 26, 2026

    If it were not so serious, it would be a joke. It is an utterly dishonest government since it was elected. Fudging serious financial issues works for a while, but when the fudging has to stop and the real situation has to be faced, the correction needed is much worse. Burnham now wants an honest discussion on free movement of people with the EU. That means he has already decided to give it away. With Immigration far too high, both legal and illegal, how can he even consider allowing that? We urgently need a recall system for MPs when they don’t do what they say. How do the people of Makerfield feel about their new MP now? A fish rots from the head down; the UK rots from the PM and Government’s dishonesty, overspending, overtaxing, and over-regulating. What have we done to deserve such a costly shambles?

  21. glen cullen
    October 26, 2026

    They should be debating the forthcoming budget, but our commons have decided today to use the limited time of the commons to debate ‘black history month’ (which they’re done for decades) with only 14 MPs in attendance …what an utter shambles and a waste of time

  22. Johan Knies
    October 26, 2026

    As Maggie Thatcher said : socialism will eventually run out of others people money.

  23. Sidney Ingleby
    October 26, 2026

    kind host:the “mass meedja” in every offering simply isn’t interested in day-to-day high-finance,matters
    national economy.I hate to think that when you rise to your feet in the upper chamber with a carefully
    and detailed exposition you are talking to empty benches and to attendees(except Govt responders)
    a thick wall

  24. miami.mode
    October 26, 2026

    Hahaha They’ve just had a rhyming quiz on TV the answer to which was Rachel Reeves and forty thieves. How appropriate.

  25. Iain Gill
    October 26, 2026

    I see Burnham is planning to spend £874 million to get about 4,000 rough sleepers off the streets.

    That’s enough to buy each of them a house. But of course the money will be spent on more council workers, and such like.

  26. Iain Gill
    October 26, 2026

    I see the government is planning a pay-per-mile tax for car drivers.

    Yet again a big change not in their manifesto.

  27. Hopeful
    October 26, 2026

    Great stuff – Victor Orban gone, Alexander Vucic gone, Bolsanaro gone, Netanyahu to go, Rama to go and Trump Maga team to be routed – the answer to all my prayers and now for Putin.

  28. Iain Gill
    October 26, 2026

    Wimbleball reservoir, which supplies more than 400,000 people in Somerset, is currently at only 13 per cent of its capacity.
    Ardingly reservoir, which supplies 280,000 people in West Sussex, is currently at only at 17 per cent of its capacity.
    Both expected to be empty by Christmas.
    Our ruling class continue with massive immigration numbers, while building no new reservoirs, and act surprised when this kind of thing happens.
    What a mess.

    1. Original Richard
      October 27, 2026

      Less than 6 miles from the South East Water Ardingly reservoir is the Weir Wood reservoir owned by Southern Water. About the same size as Ardingly this reservoir is almost full because it is re-building its treatment works. This re-building was severely delayed because Ofwat refused to allow Southern Water to proceed. Ofwat prioritised consumer bills over security of supply and this has caused some of the supply problems in the area. The cost/customer is £28 in the one year or £1/customer/year if spread out over the lifetime of 30 years. I blame Ofwat for the lack of water during our recent drought for not ordering water companies to expand supply to match our massive levels of immigration and even in this case actually refusing the re-building of a treatment works making a whole reservoir inoperative. PS: I would not be surprised if Ofwat wanted there to be a shortage of water supply to aid the propaganda that we have a climate crisis.

  29. Iain Gill
    October 26, 2026

    Construction of Hinkley Point C is likely to be halted by the local reservoirs running out of water. How much will that add to the nuclear power construction costs?

  30. Original Richard
    October 27, 2026

    “Next year Sizewell will probably need over £6 bn….”

    Is this referring to Sizewell C? If so, is this correct? The historical data from the LCCC for the Sizewell C RAB payments levy on electricity consumers’ bills (not paid out of general taxation) shows this to be approximately £1bn in 2026 and, according to the NAO Sizewell C report, rises to about £2bn in 2038, the expected completion date.
    https://www.lowcarboncontracts.uk/resources/scheme-dashboards/nuclear-rab-daily-levy-rates/
    https://www.nao.org.uk/reports/sizewell-c/#downloads

    Reply £6 bn of build cost

Comments are closed.