Yesterday I asked the government for an update on British Steel. Because I thought after 18 months of state control we were due a better assessment of the problems and signs of a plan on how to solve them I gave the Minister advance notice of what I would ask so he could get the precise briefing to inform us.
I asked to be told about the Business Plan. We were told that 18 months in they are still working on it. They have only recently appointed a new Chairman for the company and are waiting on his decisions. You would have thought there should have been a Business Plan in place before he arrived, and that if he wanted a change of Plan that would have come out in the interview process. There have been consultants working away to help the Ministers and civil servants for eighteen months.
I asked how long it would be before the 2 ageing blast furnaces need a shut down to carry out deep maintenance, as there are strict limits to what you can do with the furnaces continuously blazing. There is still no answer. I had asked this before as any normal business leader would know something as fundamental as this about the two key assets. If you need to stop the fires that means no new steel, no sales, no cashflow. It is a big task to shut down then restart a blast furnace.
I asked where the government had got to with plans to build an electric arc replacement plant in Scunthorpe. That was the plan the Conservative government had been working on with the previous owners, just as they put in place for South Wales. Again there was still no answer. The original Labour budget for steel was to provide grant for such new plants, not to pay the wages and fuel bills to keep existing plants from closure.The government does not deny that is the aim, which of course would mean closure of the blast furnaces and the loss of many jobs.
The one thing we learned from someone else’s follow up question was the total spend to date since the government stepped in has now reached £750 m, up from the recently reported £671 m. The government call this the provision of working capital, but it is to cover the losses and to finance stocks of finished steel it cannot sell other than at a big loss, or cannot sell at all to bring in cash.
I will also reveal soon that this is not the only steel loss maker taxpayers are paying for. The government’s steel nationalisation has runaway costs with no Plan for success.
October 27, 2026
John, they simply do not have a clue about running anything efficiently, management by committee at its worst.
What does Burnham, or for that matter Starmer, know about industrial production, absolutely nothing, indeed not even one Cabinet Minister has ever run a commercial business.
So how do you expect them to ask sensible questions, or pick the right so called experts to solve problems they are not even aware of.
They think spending more and more money is the answer to everything, when in fact experience and knowledge is what is required before you reach for the taxpayers cheque book.
October 29, 2026
Indeed they have not a clue about business, engineering, economics, science, energy, defence they are law, PPE, politics, sociology, English graduates and DEI net zero dopes, purveyors of the evil politics of envy.
Kemi’s speech was good but it applied just as well to the dire socialist budgets of Osborne, Hammond, Sunak and Hunt.
October 27, 2026
Tariffs on Chinese and Indian steel might be an answer.
Tariffs to equalise living costs and environmental laws seem fair to me. Unless we just don’t care about low wages and carbon in which case laws can change to make steel production here more competitive.
October 27, 2026
The ultimate aim is to stop primary steel making as it polluted using coal for carbon content. EAFs just make second rate steel by recycling scrap. We will then buy our retirements for defence etc from overseas.
In case of conflict we won’t have the capability of ramping up production of arms and like in WW2 be subject to blockades.
Pretty much like our power system, another industry destroyed by uniparty dogma.
October 27, 2026
What do you expect when you have a cabinet with zero business experience?
October 27, 2026
It is interesting to read 7 Steel UK’s answer to the question, “Why is the UK steel industry in decline?” published in March 2026. It lists 6 key factors, obtaining since the 1970s, only one of which is within its own control and that only partially.
1. Global competition intensified (by 2016, China alone was producing more steel in one year than the UK produced in nearly 50 years combined.)
2. Energy costs climbed sharply – the highest industrial electricity prices in Europe.
3. Currency pressures and economic shocks – a strong pound in the 1980s made UK steel exports expensive. Recessions, oil shocks, and IMF-driven spending cuts all hit demand.
4. Labour disputes and reliability concerns – Strikes in the 1970s–80s affected the UK’s output and hit global confidence in UK-made steel
5. Policy uncertainty and inconsistent industrial strategy – for decades, there has been no long-term UK steel plan.
6. Shifts in UK industry and demand – as UK economy moved toward services, domestic demand for certain types of steel fell.
See https://7-steeluk.com/why-is-the-uk-steel-industry-in-decline/
October 27, 2026
Indeed as expected the government are hopeless at running things and hopeless at subcontracting things too. They care not what they spend not what value if any they deliver.
So we are to get a Henry Nowak inquiry let us hope it is rather better than the sick joke Covid Inquiry, the “Grooming Gangs” Inquiry, Nottingham Inquiry (the 2023 killings and injuries involving Valdo Calocane) and the Grenfell fire.
Sally Nugent on BBC Breakfast interviewing Nigel Farage just now – yet another pathetic attempted hit job from the BBC all about whether it was racist to call Kemi a “Nigerian scammer” or not. Nigel had never said this dealt with it well but Sally was like an absurd stuck record. Almost all BBC political presenters seem to be deluded, lefty wing, big government, pro EU, climate alarmist, female, anti-Trump art graduates. So much for balance.
So what will Gollum deliver in the budget tomorrow I suspect just back door tax increases like a bank raid, this so as to keep an early election open open. I do not think an early election is remotely likely as Burnham would lose and we would likely get some dire lefty or middle of the road coalition. Plus some minimum wage increase dressed up as a government give away – these are actually just another tax increase (half goes back in tax amd NI) and then some forced cost of living increases as businesses have to recover they money they have be forced to pay out.
October 27, 2026
I have asked this before, but why does no one in the House of Commons appear to be asking these questions? The inability of a Minister to give you answers is becoming a scandal, and should be exposed as such.
October 27, 2026
Two points to add :
1. Germany is producing 15 x more steel than the UK and its gets them economically nowhere. Germany is on stand still for the last 6 years (without a Brexit!).
2. You need more speciality steel. Forget the bulk steel.
October 27, 2026
The only reason we still have any steel production in this country is because Starmer couldn’t face down the unions or his own left wing backbenchers by withdrawing funds. How could he tell them that it was the UK’s destiny to get out of the steel making business?
But why are so many ignorant of this? – Even labour activists!
Along with so many other industries in this country, steel will soon go the way of the dodo, once they have concocted a story to please the unions, not because it couldn’t adapt or because they were unproductive. Because HMG has demanded it.
The plans are there for all to see. HMG is deliberately destroying not just our industry and our way of life, but also everything worthwhile about the UK, our future.
HMG is temporarily keeping the steel plants going at a huge cost to the taxpayer, while the Chinese have demanded £1Bn in compensation, while we import ever more steel – WHAT a dreadful mess!
According to the plans in ABSOLUTE ZERO, delivering zero emissions with today’s technologies requires the phasing out of flying, shipping, lamb and beef, blast-furnace steel and cement. Despite the fact that our emissions won’t make any difference to global Co2.
Now tell me that this labour government are truly going to stimulate the economy and have nothing but our best interests at heart!
October 27, 2026
The government certainly does need a costed plan for the steel plant at Scunthorpe. Labour have put a lot of political capital into saving British Steel, which would make it very difficult for them to shut the blast furnaces now. Without Jingye’s debt repayments the company’s losses will reduce and who knows, maybe they can turn it round into profitability.
The Queen Bess furnace is indeed old, but could continue for many years without replacement. British Steel was forced to close the Queen Anne blast furnace at Scunthorpe last year after Jingye used poor quality imported coke (which damaged the lining), demonstrating their incompetence in steelmaking. Jingye had previously closed the Scunthorpe coking plant with the loss of jobs. Much of the alleged £1.3 billion loss Jingye made last year was the subsequent re-lining and restarting costs for the Queen Anne blast furnace. This furnace is now effectively brand new and will operate more efficiently with the new control system for years to come
Both blast furnaces run on cheap coal imported from Australia and the plant has secured a 337,000 ton order for rail track steel from the UK. The plant is close to the source of cheap wind electricity from the N Sea and if managed in-house using the experienced British workforce, should quickly return to profitability. Particularly if the debt that Jinye loaded the company is taken out of the equation.
The ability to make virgin steel is a vital strategic industry for this country. If it has to be re-nationalised, so be it. British steel re-forged by Sheffield Forgemasters in Sheffield is being used to make large calibre gun barrels at Rheinmetal’s new £60m gun barrel production facility in Telford. Rheinmetall says it’s new UK Gun Hall will produce 245 gun barrels and 50 breeches a year. The British defence industry welcomes Rheinmetal’s investment in the UK
Reply The blast furnaces are not powered by electricity.
October 28, 2026
@JR – Reply
Both blast furnaces run on coke, as I pointed out above. But they need electricity for the conveyors, lifting gear, extractors, running the offices etc. As they run the plant 24/7 they benefited from free weekend solar electricity all summer and the government’s reduction in electricity costs for heavy industry
October 27, 2026
Why would you expect a sensible answer from the majority of politicians and the people who surround them as they generally have no conception of how to run any sort of business?
October 27, 2026
My Lord,
Interesting piece this morning.
I would suggest that, if our government wants to continue with it’s attempt to have a war with Russia and others, then we will need our own working and efficient steel industry, to supply much of our military hardware and needs.
It’s no good expecting to rely on our “friends (sic) in Europe” given the Germans and French have offered to make submarines for Argentina.
One off topic question John if I may:… I read yesterday that the pedestrianisation of Oxford Street in London’s West End, has cost £150m for 3/4 of a mile.
I do wonder what on Earth that has actually purchased?
October 27, 2026
‘plans to build an electric arc replacement’ what we know of the World Steel market that would be 100% waste of money, recycled steel is cheep, very cheep. The UK could never compete, it doesn’t have the electricity capacity, and what it does due to Parliament interference cost 4 times those we have to compete against.
We do however desperately need the expensive Quality Steel, it is needed for infrastructure, rail, submarines etc is the strategic imperative, a necessity, a part of Parliament and its Government first job of keeping us safe.
October 27, 2026
This government seems to toss a Decisionometer Die to decide what to do, causing unwanted outcomes all over the place. Maybe they should switch to a Decisionometer Coin which has two sides rather than six. That way they might be wrong nearer to half the time.
October 27, 2026
Expecting the Public Sector managers to give answers to anything meaningful being asked is a forlorn expectation.
We are already through £240 millions spend on the Covid inquiry and nothing has been achieved from that public expenditure. I suspect the steel support spending will run into many £billions and still no public sector manager involved in the spending will be allowed to talk about where the money went or will be spent in the future.
It might be worth asking what £sum has been spent on ‘consultants’ and what have they achieved this past eighteen months. Don’t hold your breath for an answer anytime soon.
October 27, 2026
More media nonsense – the EU owned Daily Telegraph is suggesting the free movement of people is a good idea, it will bring us closer together. No longer a right of centre rag, just a WEF Euro lead publication that hates the UK
Then we get the suggestion elsewhere that there is a General Election brewing which could be announced as early as next week, once the Budget dust has settled. Reinforced again, by another YouGov Poll out today that puts Labour miles ahead of any of the so-called alternatives, so it a win, win for Burnham. Given the GE will be about joining the EU, it would pile on the distraction while they keep up the destruction and wreaking of the Country and its People. Burnham and crew demonstrate daily how they hate the nation and its people.
A GE. On that if I were a clever political manipulator(clearly I am not) I would see to it everyone knows about the secret talks between the Tories & Reform to create and alliance come an election. Clearly in the real world that would be a misplaced concept, it could never work – but what it would do (the appearance of it happening that is) put Labour and Burnham on the ‘back-foot’. Instead of as now allow them to do all the running – ring fencing the results
October 27, 2026
Nigel will have been made redundant long ago
Making plans for him didn’t work
October 27, 2026
Frightening, isn’t it, that after 18 months, there is still no plan and the losses keep mounting. Electric Arc furnaces are only any good for exsisting steel. We need blast furnaces to make new steel for our ships, tanks, armoured cars, railways and much more.
Surely this is the kind of problem a serious new PM would tackle. I wonder whether Burnham has even asked about a plan for the steel industry and how best to stop the losses. Too busy on social media, I expect.
October 28, 2026
@Keith from Leeds – and the price the UK would produce this low grade steel? It is dependant on the price of electricity the UK has the highest prices in the OECD, twice as much as the OECD average – so ho much would its steel cost when to produce it costs at least twice as much as its competitors.
No idea, no plan. I am wrong I guess, there is the plan to save ones skin get re-elected even if that is by manipulation, deception and lies.
October 27, 2026
How can electric arc furnaces be operated in the UK when electricity costs are the highest in the world? If they are subsidised, who pays? Taxpayer or other electricity users?
Same goes for AI and general computing .
October 27, 2026
The Lochaber aluminium smelter, the only one in the UK now, relies on the hydro electric power next to it to make it viable. Built alongside the hydro electric plant in 1929 when our rulers had half a clue. It only runs at 60 to 70 % capacity as it is not financially viable to top up their electric supply from the national grid.
Nothing similar will be built these days as nothing would ever get planning permission to divert water for hydro electric use. So we import from countries with no such issues.
October 27, 2026
You do the country a service by pursuing this, John. We seem to have treated ourselves to a large steelworks without having a clue what to do with it.
October 27, 2026
Do you also like “1984” by Orwell?