Based on my IEA article about nationalisation and the 1970 s

The government’s economics are being derived from  the bus industry  of Manchester. The Mayor took control of bus services and directed them from the centre. Copying the London model local government takes the fare revenue, sets the  fares and dictates  the pattern of services. Private sector bus companies compete for contracts to own and run the buses.
     The leading socialists have a view that the best economy is state planned, eliminating what they call  the extra costs of choice and competition, and expropriating the profits of successful enterprise. They see all business revenues as something the state should control or receive, often objecting to the role of profit in attracting investment and innovation. Profits to them are a loss of money for the state, to be taxed or preferably to be taken over. Ideally they would also want the state to own the operating assets and employ the staff.
    The bus industry in England went through a period of deregulation, allowing some free enterprise companies to offer new routes. New  companies could in some places be set up and established companies could expand. Innovation could thrive. Labour are gradually reversing this working towards a fully nationalised answer. They are going for  nationalisation of  the railways and steel. Their middle course of a Council controlling bus services is called franchising where all the key decisions are taken by the  public sector. The residual private companies operate on small margins to own and drive the buses.
     Many socialists want to nationalise more companies, as they struggle to manage the Post Office, HS 2, the railways  and other unruly state enterprises. In their rush back to the 1970s they have overlooked how in that decade the grim reality of the failure of the Soviet nationalised system became ever clearer. The long post war contest between planned state directed economies in the east of Europe and the freer more free enterprise economies of the west was coming to an end.
The 1980s which Mr Burnham so dislikes saw the capitulation of the Soviet model and the liberation of economies and people. The Berlin Wall finally came down. That was a symbol of people’s wish to be free themselves. They were tired of being kept in poor countries with controls over what they were allowed to think and say. In the extreme version of the USSR they  could be shot if they tried to leave for the more prosperous West.  The broken wall  was based on their appetite for the more abundant and better products  the free enterprise consumer system delivered. Shopping in West Berlin was a pleasure with plenty of choice of good products. Shopping in  the east was painful, working around shortages and empty shelves.
Past Labour governments in the 1940s, 1960s and 1970s nationalised the “commanding heights” of the economy. The big three of rail, coal and steel supported each other in an interdependent system of coal mining, steam trains and a  coal burning steel industry. All three stumbled into large losses. All three ended up closing down much of their activity and sacking the bulk of their employees.
All three failed to innovate, falling behind the advances elsewhere. Japan pioneered the pace and reliability of bullet trains, whilst the UK responded to falling passenger numbers with big cuts in lines and services.  Germany, Korea and later China came to dominate the steel market. The five large UK integrated works created by large taxpayer investment  through the nationalised industry had to plan reducing outputs and  making staff redundant, only  to be followed by eventual closure. The UK gave up on coal mining altogether and switched to gas.
The experience of the nationalised Post Office who owned the phone system was not much better. The UK continued with an older electro mechanical switching technology when the world moved on to  Crossbar then to fully electronic exchanges. The UK supply industry was left mainly servicing the UK nationalised industry with an out of date  product the rest of the world did not want to buy any more. Only after privatisation of telecoms did the UK system spend big money on catching up with the electronic technology. The UK supply industry then enjoyed a better home base to help drive an export business but the delay getting into the electronic market caused by nationalisation meant overseas competition was already well set.
Today Mr Burnham and Mr Healey are held back in their desires to nationalise more by the lack of money and the high costs of nationalising. The UK would have to compensate existing owners when taking over water or energy or transport businesses. If it failed to do so it would hit foreign investment into the country and steal from  UK savers and pension funds.  If they take over a low cost or near bankrupt business like steel it still comes with a huge public spending cost as the taxpayer has to pick up the bills for all the losses and for every pound of new investment the business needs to make. If Thames Water became available for a low price the costs of its annual capital programme to put in more reservoir capacity and to replace old and small pipes would be very large and all part of public spending.
As a result they are turning to creative accounting. Rachel Reeves relaxed the Fiscal rules substantially. She allowed the state to reduce its debt figure by deducting the value of an asset built or acquired by extra borrowing.  Whilst it is true that if you borrow too much you can always sell an asset to help you repay, the fact that you own an asset does not cancel the debt and leaves you liable for the interest. Many people own a house with a mortgage. The house is usually worth more than the debt. They still however have to pay the interest, and do not want to sell the house to pay the bill as they need somewhere to live. They are in debt.
The UK state is often a bad investor. It frequently pays too much for a new facility, whose value will be less than the debt the state incurred to buy it. The biggest current case is that of HS2. The costs have escalated giddily. It may now cost £100 bn for a rail line that just runs from London to Birmingham, duplicating other lines we already own. All of the cost is effectively being borrowed as the state is in long running large deficit. What would be the value of a new line? Nothing like the £100 bn of extra state debt. The new line will have to compete with the existing lines to win passengers and may well operate at a loss when it finally opens around 2040. In the meantime the taxpayers have to go on  paying the interest on the ever growing debt. It would be difficult  to attribute any significant sale value to the potential new line.
The case of Sizewell shows the state getting clever at finding ways to borrow that do not count. The state has the largest minority share stake in Sizewell at 45%. The government will lend  £36.6 bn to the Sizewell consortium to help build the new plant. It will do it by routing the money through the National Wealth Fund. The Fund will earn a profit by charging Sizewell more than the rate of interest the Treasury will have to pay to borrow this large sum. It will be electricity customers who pay the bills to ensure the delivery of reliable nuclear power to the grid. This will be a rare example of a profit making activity by the state based on  lending at a higher rate than the borrowing. This gain  will appear as a positive in the accounts of the National Wealth Fund. The taxpayer will however pay for the equity stake and the risks involved, whilst energy bill payers will pay for the higher  lending costs the state will charge them.
Great British Energy is building a portfolio of renewable energy investments which rely heavily on guaranteed prices, green subsidies and high taxes on rival gas production and generation. These investments will be supported by increasingly tough bans on the fossil fuel alternative and by extensive redistribution through taxes and subsidies.
Great British Rail will dictate routes, services and investment for the rail industry and will doubtless remain heavily in loss before grants. The investment will continue to be a claim on  public spending. British Steel and the Post Office remain big loss makers, with taxpayers having to pay the compensation to Post Office staff who were wrongly accused of fraud and sent to prison and to pay for the £1.3 m a day losses at steel. Neither of these businesses have convincing business plans to get into profit.
The problem with all of this is the growing public sector loses too much money and demands too much investment, forcing government to tax the private sector ever more severely. Socialists see profit making private business as potential “exploiters” to be taxed or regulated into submission. This may just result in more  businesses closing,  more investors taking their money abroad,  more companies leaving the country altogether or re siting crucial activities. We see this on a big scale with the closures of UK refineries, oil and gas production, glass, ceramics, paper, steel and many other energy intensive activities. Even higher bank taxes might switch large amounts of capital and financial activity to other centres.
Meanwhile as in the 1970s the growing nationalised estate will cost taxpayers a fortune in losses and in large and often uneconomic capital spending programmes. This will face government with difficult decisions. Will it have to replace the two blast furnaces of British Steel with an electric arc plant that would probably entail  sacking half the workforce ? Will it end up having to close the blast furnaces owing to their age and large losses, undermining the pledge to the employees? Will rail investment have to be cut back to accommodate more defence spending? Will the Post Office continue to close more branches and sell properties? Will rail losses require more service cuts? Will HS 2 suffer further delays and further cuts in the scope of the scheme?
     The government hopes more regulatory control wil lift performance. They need to puzzle why strong powers already given to the Water Regulator havecnot stopped many discharges of sewage into rivers and the sea, a practice much used by the former nationalised industry without even having to report it. Why has the Bank of England allowed inflation  over target for the whole of the  last five years? Why have rail delays and cancellations continued despite the presence  of the Rail regulator?Experience shows Regulators  struggle  to improve monopolies without competition  to keep  businesses responsive to customer needs.
    The new Chancellor  says he wants to back private sector entrepreneurs and sees the need for a lively private sector. Many of his colleagues are pursuing policies that will burden the state with more expensive white elephant public sector investments, and more high cost and loss making activities subsidised by the hard pressed taxpayers who stay to pay. In the 1980s even the Soviets woke up to the way large scale nationalisation and much central direction meant falling further and further behind  freer economies. It is such a pity Mr Burnham opposes the 1980s . He instead  dreams of the 1970s, an era of high nationalised  losses, high inflation and a  borrowing crisis when the state ran out of money.

52 Comments

  1. Stephen Sharp
    October 31, 2026

    Mr Burnham may regret the 1980s but he seems to believe the Falklands are British. I asked my Labour MP to ask him if he regarded the sinking of the Belgrano as a war crime? She refused. Had she asked him it would have been most interesting to hear his reply.

    1. Michelle
      October 31, 2026

      I’d lay good money on what his reply would be.
      Such is the calibre and beliefs of such people.
      Most in that cabinet have never held down a non-tax payer job, let alone ever been in a situation of split decisions on a war front to save your own and your men’s lives.
      I know there are a couple of ex-service men in there, and quite frankly I do not see how they can hold their heads up but that’s another issue.
      They seem to believe the heritage population will be cheerfully sending its young men off to fight for their grand posturing on the world stage!!
      They’ll be in for a shock, the mood is not conducive to that given the endless kick in the teeth the heritage population are taking from those of the globalist/communist ideology

    2. Lifelogic
      October 31, 2026

      But not it seems the Chagos Islands.

      But to be fair to Bonkers Burnham he has shifted bus fares from £3 fare to £2 and £1 paid as extra tax!

      No sorry even that daft policy has not started yet. Doubtless collecting this tax and distributing it will be far more costly than just charging it as fare. Also damaging incentives to run buses that people want to use.

      1. Lifelogic
        October 31, 2026

        Elon Musk tweet:-

        My biggest concern is that if there is a clean sweep by Democrats of the House, Senate and Presidency in 2028, they will:

        1. Make DC and Puerto Rico states to gain a strong majority in the Senate.

        2. Open the borders and legalize everyone living in America illegally to cement a permanent majority.

        3. Increase the size of the Supreme Court to gain an immediate majority.

        This would result in America becoming a permanent one-party state and the end of democracy in any meaningful sense of the word.

        All that is needed to ensure this doesn’t happen is 51 Republican senators in 2029. That is why you should vote for Republican senators this election. Other reasons are irrelevant compared to this one.

        Similar Gerrymandering fears with Burnham and Labour here – votes for children, indoctrination in schools and from the BBC types, £100 energy vouchers for 20 million households before May next year actual payments )not reduced energy or council tax bills)…

      2. iain gill
        October 31, 2026

        I like the recent trend of brits posting comments critical of immigration to the UK on social media, and proudly reminding UK police there is nothing they can do (similar posts in the UK often lead to arrests and stupid prosecutions) as they are posting from US soil where there is proper free speech, and not the fake idea of free speech in the UK.

    3. Ian B
      October 31, 2026

      @Stephen Sharp – from here that comment comes over as a very radical extremist one sided left-wing and anti UK view of things.

      Ships lost and ‘lives’ lost HMS Sheffield, HMS Ardent, HMS Antelope, HMS Coventry, SS Atlantic Conveyor, RFA Sir Galahad. Then on the other side you get Dr Rick Jolley a Royal Marine Commando being decorated by Argentina Government with the ‘Oficial Orden de Mayo’ for saving Argentine lives. – Also equally important to me as a doctor he attended my Son’s birth.

      The only crime is the left-wing ‘hate’ for the UK and its People

    4. Lynn Atkinson
      October 31, 2026

      Attacking and occupying foreign territory with no provocation whatsoever is surely a War Crime? Did Argentina think Mrs Thatcher would be weaker than a male PM and took their chance? More fool them.

  2. Mick
    October 31, 2026

    A stealth raid on income tax will bring in an additional £71billion for the Treasury by 2030-31, economists predict. This is typical liebour for you it’s nots there money so why should they give a toss, this liebour party wants to take us back in time to when the unions ran all nationalised industries and guess what folks there’s not a bloody thing we can do about it because of the stupid majority they have in parliament put there by the headless chickens , who votes for a country to go under oh I know the same gimmey gimmey useless sit on there arse’s all day or in the pub drinking there favourite tipple which we the ex stupid workers and workers pay for through our taxes because these useless parasites cannot be forced up before 12pm to work like the rest of us have done or are doing to make ends meet but liebour supporters don’t have to worry because there liebour MP will look after them with more free money if they need it, how much more do we have to put with all this crap before we end up a third world country or are we there now, boy this makes my blood boil

    1. Michelle
      October 31, 2026

      +++ I hear you Mick.

    2. Ian Wragg
      October 31, 2026

      Well said Mick. For years I left home at 5am to start a 12 hour shift I’m a power station. If I was asked to work a weekend shift overtime I list 55% in tax and insurance. As you say seeing Wetherspoons packed with the same idle crowd.
      I left the UK in 77 because of the state of the country. I watched in awe as Maggie took a machete to the state sector and curbed the unions. I returned in 99 to see Bliar starting to dismantle all the good she did. This country is in a mess after years if socialist thinking even with the so called tories
      If Burnham wins at the next election we will have full on socialist rule which will finally destroy us.
      850 invaders yesterday and no sign of it stopping.

      1. iain gill
        October 31, 2026

        I sit in spoons from time to time, every penny I have spent in there was earned by me or my dad.

    3. iain gill
      November 1, 2026

      the extra tax on savings will just force more families into benefits dependency. making us all ever more dependent on the fantastic state apparatus running all aspects of our lives.

  3. Mark B
    October 31, 2026

    Good morning.

    Nationalisation allows the growth of an ever bigger State and an ever bigger union base. A base which, indirectly contributes to the Labour Party and, directly votes for them.

    1. Michelle
      October 31, 2026

      The union base which then creates a class of drone serfs, who doff their caps to their Lords.
      They constantly remind the ‘workers’ how much better life is now they don’t have to doff their caps to the bosses, the landed gentry etc.
      Now they are free, but just don’t step on our toes, or else.

    2. Ian Wragg
      October 31, 2026

      +1

    3. Lifelogic
      October 31, 2026

      Democracy rather breaks down when you have the majority of the country sucking in the teat supplying other people’s taxes. The doom economic doom continues apace.

      JR makes lots of sensible points as usual such as “Mr Burnham opposes the 1980s. He instead dreams of the 1970s, an era of high nationalised losses, high inflation and a borrowing crisis when the state ran out of money” Doom loop economics leads to doom ery quickly

      Bonkers Burnham puts party ahead of the county, he also want more EU and rip off “renewable” energy to all further disasters. He instead dreams of the 1970s, an era of high nationalised losses, high inflation and a borrowing crisis when the state ran out of money.

      He doubtless has no grasp of science, energy, engineering, economics, defence,
      Logic, reason, maths. He seems to have concentrated on envy, resentment, chip on the shoulder poetry and English Lit. His favourite poem is the dire V by Tony Harrison. Read the poem if you to depress yourself and perhaps “understand” Bonkers Burnham.

      Andrew Marr also read English at Cambridge and described himself as a “raving leftie” and a former Maoist at university. Not sure he has changed much either since then.

      1. Ian Wragg
        October 31, 2026

        Have you seen what’s happening in Poland at present. An EU inspired coup.

        1. Lifelogic
          October 31, 2026

          Indeed an EU (attempted only I hope) coup. Then we have riots in France, Spain, Italy… big problems in Ireland and yet Bonkers Burnham wants to rejoin.

          Amazing that with modern location technology and even self driving robotic cars the Spanish cannot stop trains hitting each other at high speed. It seems the track and signalling and the moving train were both state owned and run. The stationary train was a private operator.

          1. Lifelogic
            October 31, 2026

            Preventing two large trains both on a single track hitting each other or even going to fast on sections of track should be a rather easy engineering problem to solve.

          2. iain gill
            November 1, 2026

            the Spanish signaller told the driver to proceed at full speed contrary to what the automated systems said. its human error by that signaller.

          3. iain gill
            November 1, 2026

            there were riots in Birmingham England last night, the only difference is that the news of this is being suppressed on our main stream media. I am grateful to elon for allowing me to see whats going on.

    4. Lynn Atkinson
      October 31, 2026

      That’s Socialism, not Nationalism that grows the State exponentially.
      Of course it can be argued that we are experiencing National Socialsm.

  4. Rod Evans
    October 31, 2026

    The cultural flaw with socialism is the core idea that no one should lose. The other side of that vision is no one is allowed to win. The socialist’s revulsion of profit and of those who might gain from that profit ensures profit is never an ambition of the state endeavour.
    What priorities do national industries replace the profit motive with? Where does that leave the nationalised endeavours when they look to inspire the organisation’s staff? What do they prioritise?
    We need look no further than the NHS for an answer. Profit is never a line item in the annual report. The focus is instead on a series of metrics such as waiting times and new hospital projects underway. How many new hospitals could have been built is now used as a standard measure when reporting questionable state expenditure. Meanwhile the number of NHS employees grows every year, the number of treatment wards reduces, beds cut and patients being treated on trolleys in corridors is normal. Every year the cost of the NHS increases with more and more bureaucracy needed to cope with its ever expanding staff. The result of long waiting times extended treatment regimes in ever more remote ever larger hospital locations is forcing patients into the private health care sector. There quick treatment that allows them to get on with their lives is seen for the positive it is.
    People sought their own means of transport because the cost and inconvenience of the train services other than in major cities was unacceptable to most. The private car became and is the response to the inconvenient often frustrating slow state provided rail alternative.
    The painful outcome of personal choice for state activities can be seen everywhere. The states answer is simply to ban or block that private choice from the options list hence we have penalty charges to drive in London and every major city in the land. That is the shape of state business thinking. They force the customer to use the service by economically banning all other options via fines and levies.
    In a free and democratic society It can not go on like this.

    1. Andrew Barnby
      October 31, 2026

      This is the usual political reply in Europe… “it has to be fair”, life is not like that. Now back on The Island, I lived and worked for 44 years in Europe, please just sort Brexit out properly and we will thrive. Unfortunately, Labour is Labour and the Tories were no better, so keep throwing the dice. Interesting future ahead, hopefully Conservative, don’t laugh.

  5. Sakara Gold
    October 31, 2026

    The right in British politics loves to distract from the real reason for Britain’s appaling industrial decline, which happened during the Thatcher and – particularly – the Major years.

    A quadrupling of the fossil fuel price in the 1970’s – resulting in 25% + inflation – did the damage. Plus Thatcher’s war on organised labour, her monetarist policies and Major’s follow-on war on working class who had bought their council houses. Usually self-employed.

    Thatcher’s policies put over 3 MILLION people out of work by 1982. For the first time since the 1930’s. Major put tens of thousands of potential Conservative voters out of their houses as they were repossessed. Unsurprisingly, inflation came down. Was the cure worse than the illness? We have never had a balance of payments surplus since.

    JR was involved in government during these periods. He loves to write revisionist histories. These days, it’s all net zero’s fault. And not bad management, the ascendency of the “drys” in policy and powerful manufacturing competition from Asia and the EU, who invested in automation technology

    Reply It was the Labour government 1974-9 that presided over mass redundancies, excessive debt, recession and high inflation which Thatcher had to correct in the 79-81 retrenchment

    1. Lifelogic
      October 31, 2026

      What tosh, the Tories from 1979 (my first vote then in Cambridge was for Thatcher’s Tories and I continued that ways other than voting UKIP in Majors second no change no chance election). The Tories made many errors in being far too pro EU, the ERM fiasco, closing grammar schools, falling for climate alarmism… but the main one they made was not cutting taxes and the bloated state remotely sufficiently.

    2. Bryan Harris
      October 31, 2026

      @SG – Considering how labour left the country in such a state, it was an amazing act of courage and statesmanship that Thatcher achieved anything!

      Treating the Tory party of that time as the enemy of the country just shows how immorally wrong labour supporters are.

      If it hadn’t been for Thatcher we wouldn’t have needed net-0 to ruin us, we’d still be operating in a similar fashion to Cuba, but with more insane regulations.

    3. Mark B
      October 31, 2026

      JR

      You forgot to mention the energy blackouts, the mountains’ of uncollected rubbish, the near empty shelves due to transport strikes and, worst of all, our unberied dead.

      All under a Labour government.

    4. IanT
      October 31, 2026

      I’m sure “organised labour” was required in the 19th and early 20th century SG but by the 1970s the Unions were completely out of control, being politically motivated rather than actually caring for their members well being. As for unemployment, Labour’s policies have always driven unemploymewnt up (as is happening currently). The Left still refuses to acknowledge that Labour closed more coal mines than Thatcher did. Harold Wilson closed 253 pits as against Thatcher’s 115. I still remember Arthur Scargill’s attempt to blackmail the nation into submission, which he initially succeded in doing. Fortunately Thatcher was ready for him next time he tried to do it. I lived in a mining community at that time and remember Yorkshire miners trying to blockade/black the local colliery when our miners had not been given the opportunity to vote on stike action (and would have therefore received no (Union) strike pay) – unlike the Yorkshiremen who were calling them scabs at the colliery. There were some ugly scuffles at the gates between the visiting picket and the local miners but the locals far outnumbered the visitors and I don’t think they came back again.

  6. Peter Gardner
    October 31, 2026

    There is something wrong with people who vote for Socialism. Is it their education? Did they suffer in childhood?Have they been fired and reduced to begging by filthy capitalist business owners? Or have they been so cossetted by state provision they really believe in the state being all wise such that the highest goal of their lives is satisfying the mother state ? Whatever the cause of there being so many fervent socialists the sad truth is they are all grievously mistaken. But how can they be so mistaken when the facts are clear? The one constant of socialism is that it always fails, delivering nothing but poverty and oppression and socialists always blame others, never socialism itself. One can conclude only that they have lost the balance of their minds.

    1. Lifelogic
      October 31, 2026

      Young indoctrination of immature minds like most religions, partly genetic and linked to lower or different types of IQs I suspect.

      “If you’re not a liberal when you’re young, you have no heart; if you’re not a conservative when you’re old, you have no brain.” Clearly my brain had taken over by about age 10. There is nothing remotely kind about endlessly augmenting the numbers who live off the backs of others – quite the reverse. They need to learn how to work and fend for themselves. It is in their own interests to do this and to be forces to do this.

      1. Lifelogic
        October 31, 2026

        Forced whenever practical & possible that is.

  7. William Long
    October 31, 2026

    I do wish more Conservatives were putting out this stark message with such clarity. Only by doing so will they get back into power.

  8. Berkshire Alan
    October 31, 2026

    Yes have lived through it having started my engineering apprenticeship in 1964, so witnessed all of which you speak personally John.
    The present day clowns in Government do not have a clue, its all theory to them, no factual experience in any commercial industry, past or present.
    Life is simple really, or at least should be, as is business, in both cases you need to end up with a surplus at the end of the week, month, year, for you to be in control of your life, otherwise it all starts to get more, and more complicated as you lose control, both over your own life, or business.
    The problem the last 30 years is that successive Governments with their actions have made everything more and more complicated, Tax, Benefits, Energy, Pensions, Health Care, Social Care, and even the Law, thus few politicians even understand any system themselves properly, we even now have Ministers that do not understand the tax system, even with so called expert advice.
    Thus we are now all drowning in our own self made chaos, because of Government incompetence, ignorance and the want to control every aspect of our lives.
    The final straw is that they think it is all necessary, and that they are doing a such good job, we need even more complication, when the opposite is true.

  9. iain gill
    October 31, 2026

    you should not be afraid to mention the NHS in such a description of nationalisation. most real voters know the service is very bad. health care in Australia, New Zealand, Belgium, Italy, to name but a few is thousands of times better than the UK. Dom Cummings assessment that right wing parties should not challenge the NHS is wrong. if the argument was put properly there is a massive desire for far better health care in this country.

  10. Robert Mcdonald
    October 31, 2026

    I think your article highlights the well-known experience that socialism never works.

  11. iain gill
    October 31, 2026

    I listen to Labour and Liberal politicians who simultaneously argue for more parental choice of which school their kids go to, but also arguing that catchment areas should be much smaller to cut bus and car journeys to school.
    Indeed I know one secondary school which has expanded greatly, taken in far more children from far away… and now the buses are dangerously overcrowded. and the politicians and planners refuse to support expanded bus services to support the school population that they themselves have planned. and no buses later in the evening to support after school activities and clubs.
    we have state created problems of pupils struggling to get to and from school due to the way the state constrains buses.
    add in the new rules from central government which allow phones to be confiscated for minor trivial rule breaking with no notice, when the bus tickets are on a phone app. this allows schools to cause pupils to be stuck at school after the last bus has gone. a terrifying prospect for a 11 year old pupil.
    and with no bus capacity more parents take their kids in cars causing more road congestion.
    the state planned approach is a disaster for kids travelling to school.

  12. Handbrake
    October 31, 2026

    The 1970’s 1980s was a different time with different people however there is a new team in place now and they should be fully supported. Labels like socialism or socialist are in the realm of Trumps mad America at this time but count for very little because that’s what they are ‘labels’. We here live in the real world of grownups so Government has to be allowed to do what’s best for the country. Burnham & Co are in the driving seat now and there’s no alternative that I can see since the Conservative party has largely devoured itself from the inside/ out.

    1. IanT
      October 31, 2026

      We’ve had 30 months of this Government now HB and all that has changed is that the new salesman is much better than the first one – but (what ever ‘label’ is put on the bottle) it’s the same old snake oil that he’s selling.

  13. Ian B
    October 31, 2026

    Unfortunately the ones doing the damage, creating the destruction are not listening, alternatively they blame others for blocking them going full on Marxist State.

    The only problem see is that history and their ideology teaches them is that unless they are in full control with the people enslaved and bowing to their ‘personal’, very ‘personal wishes’. Socialism is never about the nation or its people, its about the individuals that run the Politburo and nothing else.

    Ask yourself, why is it the UK alone in the Nations that define themselves as ‘free’, don’t permit regular elections in line with the actual ‘free world’, why does the UK Parliament shun the duty of seeking validation for a chosen direction. Why do those with power seek to Gerrymander, bend and warp the meaning of elections and democracy? Then you have the answer as to why the 1940s, 1960s and 1970s are important to Socialism they identify unfinished projects and why they need maximum time between elections to construct points of no return.

    John, I think you missed the ‘naughties’ from the socialist destruction of the UK projects. Tell me when will Gordon Brown’s misadventure debts be paid?

  14. Bryan Harris
    October 31, 2026

    … a pity Mr Burnham opposes the 1980s . He instead dreams of the 1970s, an era of high nationalised losses, high inflation and a borrowing crisis when the state ran out of money,

    And a time when manufacturing in Britain almost closed down.

    Only a deranged socialist mind would want the 70’s back – labour really showed us all what they could do and it was far from pretty, nice or even survival. You’d have thought that even Labour would have learned the lessons of the 70’s by now, but instead, being ideological rather than logical, they intend to repeat the failures of the past to achieve the aims of net-0 which actually does require us to have no realistic industry and certainly no future.

    It is the era of labour misrule that should be taught in schools so that everyone understands how destructive labour can be, rather than the woke DEI nonsense our kids get implanted with.

  15. Sakara Gold
    October 31, 2026

    Yet more guff in the right-wing press this weekend alleging “excessive” windfarm curtailment – which is apparently being looked at by Healey with a view to cancelling the recent, highly successful AR7 renewables round

    Total renewable curtailment across the UK in 2025 was less than 10 TWh annually, out of total UK electricity production of about 293.6 TWh. This wasted energy represents approximately ~3.4% of total UK electricity production across all power sources combined, highlighting the urgent economic and environmental necessity of rapidly completing the major grid infrastructure upgrades. That’s just £15/pa on your average £2000 energy bill, or roughly 4p a day

    If Labour really want to reduce the cost of energy the way to do it is to cancel the ruinously expensive carbon capture and storage projects. The total cost of deploying and operating CCS in the UK is “up to” £408 billion by 2050, according to independent estimates by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, while the Climate Change Committee projects a baseline infrastructure cost of £264 billion. Huge savings if Labour scrap it

    1. Sam
      October 31, 2026

      SG
      Are you sure of your figires for Government funding of Carbon Capture and Storage?
      The Governent say it is £22 billion over 25 years.

  16. Bloke
    October 31, 2026

    Economic issues were bouncing people around in the 1970s, especially with the oil crisis, yet it was a highly exciting time for young folk with flower power, mini skirts and so much interesting change going on.

  17. Lynn Atkinson
    October 31, 2026

    If the asset is offset against Govt Borrowing, then any asset in ‘negative equity’ should also be calculated and impact the bottom line.
    So what is the Market Value of the NHS, education facilities, the Asylum industry?
    I think we should embrace the Reeves approach and show the Government it’s own balance sheet for ‘U.K. Plc.’
    Then perhaps we can make the Directors (MPs and Civil Servants) liable?
    There are more ways of killing the cat than choking it on cream.

  18. Sidney Ingleby
    October 31, 2026

    P.G.: I await the Hefner and SG rebuttals of your psychiatric analysis of their thought processes.
    Returning to nationalisation.Currently my energy use is entirely electric.I have 1 supplier.
    Apart from my billing for kwh usage(which goes to them-less 5%tax?) the statement includes just
    under 50p per day delivery system maintenance.As gas and electricity suppliers are private companies I wonder
    if the network system is also private or Nation-Owned.When we sell power to the continent and Eire the charge
    is not levied.The charge amounts to some £7.75bn(gas and electric) going to a bank account somewhere.

  19. glen cullen
    October 31, 2026

    671 illegals arrived yesterday …..number carrying knives; unknown

    1. iain gill
      October 31, 2026

      number carry knifes, at least one because they were bragging about it openly on video which is now on YouTube

    2. Diane
      November 1, 2026

      Glen C: To add a short recap: Total for 01-31 October inclusive: 2932 / 39 boats.
      Figures appear consistent for the last 6 months May to Oct: May: 2726, Jun: 2742, Jul: 2316, Aug: 2571, Sep: 2683, Oct: 2932.
      Total no of boats over those 6 months : 217 – plus the 2 which came & landed unaccompanied in September.
      All official website figures as reported.

  20. glen cullen
    October 31, 2026

    We were defo happier in the 70s, just look at the news across europe today, the politicians disconnect with the people is almost complete, the lack of democracy, mass migration, wokeness, policies of net-zero and world governance has destroyed tradition, communities and our christian society …..going for a pint before it gets taxed again

  21. Andrew Barnby
    October 31, 2026

    Sir John, you mentioned the Post Office. Four or so years ago our local Post Office about a mile outside Scarborough was closed, we all had to traipse into town and queue at W H Smith for a stamp, as our main Post Office in town had closed beforehand. Now I have heard that the Smith and Jones ‘post office’ is closing, probably along with the shop itself. We seem to have lost the ability to use common sense and logic through so called management. If someone cannot run a Smith and Jones and a Post Office together in a large town then there is no hope. That the East European ‘investor’ was allowed to take over the Post Office is idiotic, where is the splendid name with a good reputation, Royal Mail now in all this.
    Sadly I see little future for businesses, all the old established names have gone and will not return. American style ‘investment’ greed and short term-ism has taken over, walking away with all the money.

    1. Lynn Atkinson
      October 31, 2026

      It’s TGJones which has applied to the Court and received permissions for extraordinary action to avoid bankruptcy. Many are closing, their A1 shop landlords, ie the most profitable are receiving 25% of the rent for a year although they were made to defer the other 75% until 2029 rather than writing it off. That assumes, of course that TGJones still exists in 2039.
      So the Post Office, piggybacking in other peoples shops, has no locus. No independence.

Comments are closed.